|Year : 2010 | Volume
| Issue : 3 | Page : 135-140
Pilgrims satisfaction with ambulatory health services in Makkah, 2008
Ibrahim A Al-Hoqail1, Abdelshakour M Abdalla2, Abdalla A Saeed2, Nasir A Al-Hamdan2, Ahmed A Bahnassy2
1 Department of Dermatology, College of Medicine, King Saud University, Riyadh, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia
2 Department Community Medicine, King Saud Bin Abdul-Aziz University for Health Sciences, King Fahad Medical City, Riyadh, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia
|Date of Web Publication||29-Dec-2010|
Abdelshakour M Abdalla
Community Medicine Consultant, Faculty of Medicine, King Saud Bin Abdul-Aziz University for Health Sciences, King Fahad Medical City, PO Box 59048, Riyadh 11525
Kingdom of Saudi Arabia
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
| Abstract|| |
Objective: The main objective of this study was to assess the level and correlates of patients' satisfaction with ambulatory health services provided for pilgrims during Hajj period in 2008. Materials and Methods: This was a facility-based, cross-sectional study conducted in the Makkah region during the Hajj season in December 2008. A two-stage technique was used to select 500 patients from those who attended the ambulatory health services. One hundred subjects were selected by systematic random sampling (every fifth) from each of the five hospitals included in the study and asked to fill in a pilot-tested self-administered questionnaire. A total of 487 questionnaires were analyzed. Descriptive statistics and t-test, Mann Whitney test and ANOVA, or Kruskal-Wallis test was used as appropriate after checking for normality. Level of significance level was set to be <0.05 throughout the study. Results: From 478 subjects analyzed, 390 (81.6%) were man, 345 (72.2%) were married, 28.9% had either intermediate or high secondary school education, and 2.4% were skilled laborers. The total satisfaction score for health facilities was 20.45 ± 4.03 of 25. The satisfaction scores were 20.15 ± 4.7 of 25 for patient satisfaction with physicians and 21.35 ± 4.5 for patient satisfaction with paramedical personnel. The overall satisfaction score was 61.5 ± 4.5 of 75 points. There were significant relations between total satisfaction of health facilities with education level and with occupation (P = 0.012, 0.001, respectively). The total satisfaction of patients with physicians was significant only with education level. The overall satisfaction score had a significant relation with occupation (P = 0.03), but a borderline relation with the education level (P = 0.056). Conclusion: Satisfaction with ambulatory Hajj health services is acceptable. Some physicians and waiting area services need special attention to improve satisfaction levels with ambulatory health in the subsequent Hajj seasons.
Keywords: Ambulatory health services, Hajj pilgrims, Makkah
|How to cite this article:|
Al-Hoqail IA, Abdalla AM, Saeed AA, Al-Hamdan NA, Bahnassy AA. Pilgrims satisfaction with ambulatory health services in Makkah, 2008. J Fam Community Med 2010;17:135-40
|How to cite this URL:|
Al-Hoqail IA, Abdalla AM, Saeed AA, Al-Hamdan NA, Bahnassy AA. Pilgrims satisfaction with ambulatory health services in Makkah, 2008. J Fam Community Med [serial online] 2010 [cited 2021 Feb 26];17:135-40. Available from: https://www.jfcmonline.com/text.asp?2010/17/3/135/74331
| Introduction|| |
Measuring satisfaction in many communities has increased with the development and growth of the consumerism. Client satisfaction surveys have been used extensively in developed countries and have grown substantially in many developing countries. ,,,, The last two decades have witnessed an increase in the attention given to users' satisfaction with health services.  This reflects the value of consumers' opinions about the quality of a product or service. Patient satisfaction is an important element in evaluating the quality of health care services, and in predicting patients' behavioral patterns after receiving the services. In addition to measuring client satisfaction, such studies can identify facility attributes or practices that increase satisfaction and utilization, which may lead to favorable outcomes.
Several tools were used to study consumer satisfaction. These included interviews and open-ended questions which produced detailed information that is usually difficult to analyze. More structured multiple-item questionnaires with Likert scale response categories produced data which can be handled easily but require close attention to validity and reliability. ,,,,,,
Hajj (Pilgrimage) is a special season where more than two million Muslims from more than 150 countries gather every year at the holy shrine (Al-Mashaer) to perform this important ritual of Islam. Hajj is performed in Makkah and Al-Mashaer in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (KSA), which includes Mina, Mozdalifah and Arafat. The ritual starts on the 8th and ends on the 13th day of Dhul Hijjah, the 12th month of the lunar Islamic calendar year. It corresponded to December 5 to 11, 2008 in this study. The government of the KSA through Ministry of Health provides free health services for all pilgrims during Hajj period.
The main objectives of this study were to assess the level and correlates of satisfaction of pilgrims attending Hajj ambulatory health services. To the best of our knowledge, this was the first survey of its kind in the Kingdom to focus on ambulatory Hajj health services. We hope that the findings of this study may be of help in improving the ambulatory health services during Hajj season.
| Materials and Methods|| |
This was a facility-based, cross-sectional study conducted during the Hajj season for one week from December 5 to 11, 2008. A two-stage sampling technique was used. In the first stage, five hospitals (of the ten hospitals) providing health services for pilgrims in Makkah and Mina were selected randomly. In the second stage, a systematic random sampling with five-interval spacing was used to select 100 patients from each hospital, giving a total of 500 patients of those who attended the ambulatory health services during the time of the study. Selected subjects completed a predesigned, pilot-tested self-administered questionnaires.
The questionnaire consisted of three main parts beside the demographic variables. The first part consisted of questions related to satisfaction with the conformability of the patient in the health facility; the second part contained questions measuring satisfaction with the physician; and the third part measured satisfaction with other health team personnel. Each section had five subcategories. All questions measuring satisfaction were rated on a Likert scale of five points ranging from 1 (lowest satisfaction) to 5 (highest satisfaction scores), so the maximum satisfaction score for each section was 25 points and maximum overall satisfaction score for the three sections was 75 points.
The questionnaire was reviewed by three specialists in community medicine, nursing, and health service administration to assess face validity, and resulted in an agreement on 14 of the 15 items. Reliability of the questionnaire was assessed using Cronbach' alpha coefficient. It was 87.0%. The data were collected by trained Medical students from faculty of Medicine, King Fahad Medical City, who were available to help illiterate and non-Arabic speaking pilgrims in completing the questionnaires. Verbal and written confidentiality was assured and patients were informed that the data would be used only for the stated research purposes, and that their participation was totally voluntary.
Permission for the study was obtained from authorities concerned. All data were checked for completeness, entered into a personal computer, and analyzed using SPSS version 17. Descriptive statistics and t-test, Mann Whitney test and ANOVA, or Kruskal-Wallis test was used as appropriate after checking for normality. Significance level was set as <0.05 throughout the study.
Hajj is one of the five pillars of Islam. It is a set of acts of worship to be performed in and around Makkah at least once in a lifetime by every Muslim who satisfies certain conditions.
| Results|| |
Of the 500 subjects who participated in the study, 22 (4.4%) were excluded because their responses were missing. Of the remaining 478 subjects, 390 (81.6%) were man, 345 (72.2%) were married, 133 (28.9%) had either intermediate or high secondary school education, and 127 (27.4%) were skilled laborers [Table 1].
[Table 2] shows the descriptive summary of the studied items. Total satisfaction score for health facilities was 20.45 ± 4.03, while it was 20.15 ±4.7 for satisfaction with the physician, and 21.35 ± 4.5 with the paramedical personnel, all of 25 points. The overall satisfaction score was 61.5 ± 4.5 of 75 points [Table 2].
[Table 3] shows the relation between total satisfaction scores for each part with demographic variables. Significant relationship was noticed between total satisfaction with the health facilities and each of educational level and occupation (P = 0.012, 0.001, respectively), whereas no significant relationships were noticed with marital status and gender. With respect to the total satisfaction of the patients with physician, it was significant only with educational level (P = 0.042). With regard to satisfaction score of the patients with the other health team members, there was no statistical significance with any of the demographic variables. For the overall satisfaction score, a significant difference was noticed with occupation (P = 0.03), whereas there was borderline significance as regards to the educational level (P = 0.056).
|Table 3: Relation between satisfaction scores and some demographic variables|
Click here to view
| Discussion|| |
Consumers' satisfaction with health services provided has been widely studied mostly in developed countries. Patients' perceptions are valued and are used to measure overall quality and an outcome of consultations and other encounters between providers and consumers. Satisfaction with ambulatory care has significantly influenced consumers' behavior in looking for health care, compliance with treatment, and return to the same care facility. , Health care providers must consider whether patient expectations of their services can be managed and if so, how this can be done. Dissatisfaction with health care services could be reduced if consumers knew what to expect, and their views and suggestions on what is actually provided are taken seriously.
The overall mean consumers' satisfaction with ambulatory health services provided in this study was 61.5 of 75 points (82%). Hajj is a ritual performed only in Saudi Arabia and the authors are not aware of any published studies on satisfaction with ambulatory Hajj health services. This discussion will focus mainly on comparing our results with studies in ambulatory health settings in the Kingdom and other countries.
Previous studies in the Saudi Arabia, some neighboring countries, and other Muslim countries reported overall satisfaction scores ranging from 60 to 90% with Primary Health Care settings. ,,,,,,, The relatively high satisfaction in Hajj may be due to the different nationalities of the consumers. The service is free and some consumers from poor developing countries with relatively poorly developed health services are likely to respond much more favorably. Also, Hajj is a religious activity during which those performing it mostly have peace of mind, are accommodating, and generally less critical and less demanding. However, user surveys, particularly exit surveys, typically uniformly show high satisfaction with services. One likely reason is 'courtesy bias,' whereby respondents are reluctant to express negative opinions resulting in an overestimation of satisfaction. 
Consumers with lower educational level and those working as unskilled laborers were significantly more satisfied than those of higher educational level working in skilled jobs. All other variables studied were not significantly related to the overall and differential satisfaction with services. It appears that the less-educated and unskilled laborers were less demanding and their expectations were much lower than those of the highly educated, skilled, and professional persons.
Satisfaction with physicians' services in this study scored the lowest satisfaction level compared with allied health and reception services. However, this satisfaction score is better than satisfaction scores with physicians in ambulatory settings in Saudi Arabia (2.31-2.56 points of 5 (46.2-51.2%))  and Kuwait City in Kuwait (2.21 points of 5 [44.2%]).  Satisfaction with physicians' services significantly affects satisfaction with health services, particularly ambulatory services. Areas of physician service which need attention include clinical examination, giving explanations, and responding to queries. Studies have confirmed that physicians can enhance satisfaction by spending a little more time to talk to the patient to exchange views and give better explanation and information. ,, Training in communication skills increases open discussion and improves physician's sensitivity to patients and their general satisfaction.  Clinical examination can be improved by increasing the number of physicians at the clinics, so that more time can be spent by the doctor to examine each patient.
Marital status, age, or gender was not significantly associated with all services. Other studies have reported that older patients tended to have significantly higher satisfaction with services provided. ,, Older subjects were generally more conservative and less demanding than younger ones. Gender and marital status were not significantly associated with satisfaction in this study, which is in accord with findings of other studies, ,, although a recent study found that females with higher incomes were more satisfied with primary health services. 
Several studies have reported that a comfortable physical environment was a factor in encouraging utilization of the services and increasing satisfaction. The main concern of the consumers in this study was the lack of space in the waiting area. The areas around the holy shrines are very limited, which gives concern to the health services and all other services. It is hoped that there would be more space made available in future.
The subjects were also concerned about many aspects of pharmacy and the services of pharmacist. There was poor satisfaction with pharmacy services because pharmacists had failed to give sufficient information on the side effects of drugs and precautions that need to be taken. Pharmacists should play an active role in providing information on drug interactions and side effects and should be ready to answer patient's queries. Many studies have shown that pharmacy services in ambulatory settings are a cause of concern to many consumers. , Results of this study appear to support findings of some studies which showed that the less-educated consumers were more satisfied than the more educated. ,,,, Many other studies did not find significant consistent association between education and satisfaction. ,,
Consumers who work at semiskilled or unskilled jobs were significantly more satisfied in the present study, while a previous study in Riyadh found that the highest satisfaction score was among teachers (96%). 
In a previous study in Riyadh city, married consumers were more satisfied than those who were single.  Our findings in only a few services appeared to agree with this. Widowed subjects tended to have higher satisfaction with most services in our study, but the differences were not significant. Many studies have not shown any significant relationship between marital status and satisfaction. ,,,,
The results of this study, in general, revealed no significant consistent pattern of association of satisfaction with the variables studied, except for occupation and education. Evidently, patients' socio-demographic variables have been studied in several communities but their relation to opinions and attitudes, and their association with satisfaction have been rather inconsistent and at times contradictory. ,,,,, Several factors are associated with the positive attitudes and satisfaction of patients with the health services. These include manpower characteristics, resources and service organization, distance travelled, travel and waiting times, working hours, and the attitudes of the patient towards life itself. Also, methodology of the study and whether self-administered or interviews were used to collect data, the types, number and sequence of questions asked, the timing and setting may all have affected the level of satisfaction. Although studies may be costly, information gathered on consumers' opinions about the services provided, the methods used, can lead to many changes that may be beneficial to the consumers, the health team, and the entire health system.
| Conclusion|| |
There was acceptable satisfaction with ambulatory health services for the Hajj. Problems with physicians and services in the waiting area need to be addressed in order to raise the satisfaction level with ambulatory health services during future Hajj seasons. We recommend a larger scale more comprehensive study covering all levels of health services.
Because of the special circumstances of the Hajj, the questionnaire did not include all parameters affecting satisfaction. The sample size and duration of study were also affected by the special status and duration of Hajj season. The study design was cross sectional with its limitations. Patients' feedbacks were subjective.
| Acknowledgment|| |
The authors thank all patients who participated in the study for their cooperation and time. We also appreciate the role played by all the students who participated in this study.
| References|| |
|1.||Glick P. How reliable are surveys of client satisfaction with health services? Evidence from a matched facility and household data in Madagascar. Soc Sci Med 2009;68:368-79. |
|2.||Drain M. Quality improvement in primary care and the importance of patient perceptions. J Ambul Care Manage 2001;24:30-47. |
|3.||Andrzejewski N, Lagua RT. Use of customer satisfaction survey by health care regulators: A tool for total quality management. Pub Health Rep 1997;112:206-10. |
|4.||Hudak P, McKeever P. The metaphor of patients as customers: Implications for measuring satisfaction. J Clin Epidemiol 2003;56:103-8. |
|5.||Atkinsona S, Haran D. Individual and district scale determinants of users′ satisfaction with primary health care in developing countries. Soc Sci Med 2005;60:501-13. |
|6.||Jenkinson C, Coulter A, Bruster S. The picker patients experience questionnaire: Development and validation using data from in-patient surveys in five countries. Int J Qual Health Care 2002;14:353-8. |
|7.||Scholle S, Weisman C, Anderson R, Camacho F. The development and validation of the primary care satisfaction survey for women. Women′s Health Issues2004;14:35-50. |
|8.||Wolf M, Putman S, James S, Stiles W. The medical interview satisfaction scale: Development of a scale to measure patient perceptions with physicians′ behavioours. J Behav Med 1978;1:391-401. |
|9.||Baker R. Development of a questionnaire to assess patients′ satisfaction with consultation in general practice. Br J Gen Pract 1990;40:487-90. |
|10.||Kinnersley P, Stott N, Peters T, Harvey I, Hackett P. A comparison of methods for measuring satisfaction with consultation in primary care. Fam Med 1996;13:41-51. |
|11.||Williams B. Patient satisfaction: A valid concept. Soc Sci Med 1994;38:509-16. |
|12.||Van Campen C, Sixma H, Friel R, Kersens J, Peters L. Quality of care and patient satisfaction: A review of measuring instruments. Med Care Res Rev 1995;52:109-33. |
|13.||Garman AN, Garcia J, Hargreaves M. Patient satisfaction as a predictor of return-to-provider behavior: Analysis and assessment of financial implications. Qual Manag Health Care 2004;13:75-80. |
|14.||Bendall-Lyon D, Powers TL. The impact of structure and process attributes on satisfaction and behavioral intentions. J Serv Mark 2004;18:114-21. |
|15.||Al-Sakkak M, Al-Nowaiser N, Al-Khashan H, Al-Abdrabulnabi A, Jaber R. Patient satisfaction with primary health care services in Riyadh. Saudi Med J 2008;29:432-6. |
|16.||Abdalla A, Saeed A, Magzoub M, Reerink E. Consumer satisfaction with primary health care services in Hail City, Saudi Arabia. Saudi Med J 2005;26:1030-2. |
|17.||Al Doghaither A, Saeed A, Mohammed B. Satisfaction and correlates of patient satisfaction with primary health care center services in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia. Qatar Med J 2001;10:34-8. |
|18.||Margolis S, Al-Marzouqi S, Revel T, Reed RL. Patient satisfaction with primary health care services in the United Arab Emirates. Int J Qual Health Care 2003;15:241-9. |
|19.||Al-Eisa I, Al-Mutar R, Al-Turki A. Patients′ satisfaction with primary health care services at capital health region, Kuwait. Middle East J Fam Med 2005;3:10-6. |
|20.||Al-Doghaither AH, Abdelrahman B, Saeed A, Al-Kamil A, Magzoub M. Patients′ satisfaction with primary health care centers in Kuwait City, Kuwait. J Fam Comm Med 2001;3:59-65. |
|21.||Gadallah M, Zaki B, Rady M, Anwer W, Sallam I. Patient satisfaction with primary health care services in two districts in lower and upper Egypt. East Mediterr Health J 2003;9:422-30. |
|22.||Hanse P, Peter D, Viswanathan K, Krishna D, Mashkoor A, Burnham G. Client perceptions of the quality of primary care services in Afghanistan. Int J Qual Health Care 2008;20:384-91. |
|23.||Lindelow M, Wagstaff A. Health facility surveys: An introduction. World Bank Policy Research Working Paper 2953. Available from: http://www-wds.worldbank.org [last accessed on 2003]. |
|24.||Daniel A, Burn R, Horarik S. Patient complaints about medical practice. Med J Aust 1999;170:598-602. |
|25.||Gross D, Zyzanski S, Borawaski E, Cebul R, Stange K. Patient satisfaction with time spent with their physician. J Fam Med 1998;47:133-7. |
|26.||Sixma H, Preeuwenberg P, van der Pasch M. Patient satisfaction with the general practitioner: A two-level analysis. Med Care 1998;36:212-29. |
|27.||Hallm J, Roter D. Patient gender and communication with physicians: Results of a community-based study. Women′s Health 1995;1:77-95. |
|28.||Campbell J, Ramsay J, Green J. Age, gender, socioeconomic, and ethnic differences in patients′ assessments of primary health care. Qual Health Care 2001;10:90-5. |
|29.||Al-Faris E, Khoja T, Falouda M, Saeed A. Patients′ satisfaction with accessibility and services offered in Riyadh health centers. Saudi Med J 1996;17:11-7. |
|30.||Al Dousari M, Al Mutawa A, Al Mithen N. Patient satisfaction according to type of primary healthcare practitioner in the capital health region, Kuwait. Kuwait Med J 2008;40:31-8. |
|31.||Bodur S, Zdemur Y, Kara F. Outpatient satisfaction with health centers in urban areas. Turk J Med Sci 2002;32:409-14. |
|32.||Jones RB, Carnon AG, Wylie H, Hedley AJ. How do we measure consumer opinions of outpatient clinics? Public Health 1993;107:235-41. |
|33.||Cohen G. Age and health status in a patient satisfaction survey. Soc Sci Med 1996;42:1085-93. |
|34.||Weiss G. Patients satisfaction with primary medical care: Evaluation of socio- demographic and predispositional factors. Med Care 1988;26:383-91. |
|35.||Pascoe G. Patient satisfaction in Primary Health care: A literature review and analysis. J Eval Program Plann 1983;6:185-210. |
[Table 1], [Table 2], [Table 3]