|Year : 2001 | Volume
| Issue : 2 | Page : 35-43
A non-comparative descriptive study of the risk factors for childhood disability, and the rehabilitation services in Jeddah, Saudi Arabia
Sherine Shawky, Bahaa A Abalkhail, Nadia K Soliman, Mohammad N Kordi
Department of Community Medicine and Primary Health Care, College of Medicine and Allied Health Sciences, King Abdulaziz University, Jeddah, Saudi Arabia
|Date of Web Publication||30-Jul-2012|
P.O. Box 115, Jeddah 21411
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
| Abstract|| |
Objectives: Identify the possible risk factors in our community that may influence having a disabled child, and identify the rehabilitation services available to disabled children.
Methods: Data were collected from six rehabilitation institutes for auditory, visual and mental disabilities in Jeddah City during April 1999. Complete data available on sociodemographic and medical risk factors were extracted from the institutes' files. Personal interviews with the disabled were conducted to confirm information on the services offered to them.
Results: Certain modifiable risk factors affecting child health, such as early and late marriages and childbearing, illiteracy, unemployment, high parity and consanguineous marriages still exist in our community. Occupational hazards were also detected among military workers and working women. Disabilities related to perinatal health with antenatal, natal and postnatal components were also observed. According to resources available, various rehabilitation services are offered to disabled children.
Conclusion: The need for intervention in two areas of health is crucial. The first is the prevention of future disabilities through continuous research, modification of unfavorable habits and the strengthening of the quality of perinatal care. The second is the improvement of rehabilitation services in order to raise the quality of life of the handicapped.
Keywords: Childhood disability, handicapped, risk factors, consanguineous mar-riage, perinatal care, Saudi Arabia.
|How to cite this article:|
Shawky S, Abalkhail BA, Soliman NK, Kordi MN. A non-comparative descriptive study of the risk factors for childhood disability, and the rehabilitation services in Jeddah, Saudi Arabia. J Fam Community Med 2001;8:35-43
|How to cite this URL:|
Shawky S, Abalkhail BA, Soliman NK, Kordi MN. A non-comparative descriptive study of the risk factors for childhood disability, and the rehabilitation services in Jeddah, Saudi Arabia. J Fam Community Med [serial online] 2001 [cited 2020 Jan 17];8:35-43. Available from: http://www.jfcmonline.com/text.asp?2001/8/2/35/99186
| Introduction|| |
It has been estimated that over three-quarters of the world's disabled children under 15 years of age live in developing countries  . The burden of childhood disability as a public health problem and the services offered to this category of patients in developing countries remain relatively unrecognized. There is a major information gap in the Third World concerning the magnitude of the problem and the needs, in terms of prevention, rehabilitation, medical and social requirements, to combat this problem. ,,
Saudi Arabia has undergone rapid economic development in the last few decades. This is consequently reflected in improved health care services and the decrease in infant mortality.  Overtly disabled children are now more likely to survive in greater numbers and pose a major drain on the health and social services. Many studies on the subject have been done in the Kingdom, each focusing on a single type of child disability. Definitions in these studies have not been uniform, neither have the data been published. A recent national survey in the Kingdom reported the prevalence of major disabilities as approximately 4.0% of the population.  Epidemiologic studies tackling the potential risk factors specific to our community are still lacking. Overall evaluation of perinatal care and programs directed at disabled children are mostly hospital-based. Nevertheless, there are government and private rehabilitation institutes all over the Kingdom that offer various services to this category of the population.
An analysis of the problem of disability in the Kingdom would give an indication of the situation in the Middle East and emphasize potential risk factors specific to the traditions in the region. Basic data from the specialized rehabilitation institutes are of enormous importance as they constitute data banks suitable for an evaluation of the problem as well as the development of relevant local prevention programs and health interventions directed at improving the quality of life. Consequently, the study was initiated with basic data from rehabilitation institutes for disabled children to give some insight into (a) the potential risk factors and (b) the services available for disabled children.
| Material and Methods|| |
Data were collected from the major governmental rehabilitation institutes in Jeddah that specialize in single disability care. There are three specialized governmental institutes for boys and three twin institutes for girls. The Al-Amal Rehabilitation Institute, established in 1970, provides special education for the auditory disabled (deaf-mutes) with an IQ of at least 70. The Al-Noor Rehabilitation Institute, established in 1983, offers special education for visually disabled children with visual acuity not exceeding 6/60 and IQ of at least 70. The Al-Tarbyia Al-Fikrayia Rehabilitation Institute, established in 1975, is for the education of mentally disabled children with minimum IQ of 50.
Data were collected during April 1999 on all children in the six governmental rehabilitation institutes in Jeddah. Only the complete files of children present in the institutes during the data collection period were considered. Basic data on sociodemographic status and the potential risk factors were extracted by trained medical students under the direct supervision of medical staff, from the institutes' social, psychological and medical files. Trained medical students interviewed the disabled children to confirm the data collected on services provided.
Data and statistical analysis
Data entry and analysis were done using SPSS for Windows (Version 9.05). Three cohorts were defined: the auditory disabled (deaf-mutes), the visually disabled, and the mentally disabled children. Parity was defined as the mother's parity at childbirth including the index child. Multiparity was defined as having at least 5 children, including the index-disabled child. Spontaneous abortion, fetal death and/or infant mortality were defined as having had at least one experience during the mother's reproductive life preceding the birth of the index disabled child. All conditions of maternal and disabled child's health considered were those diagnosed by physicians and recorded in the medical files. Chi-square test was used to detect significant differences in the proportions among the three cohorts.
| Results|| |
A total of 421 auditory disabled, 178 visually disabled, and 666 mentally disabled children were enrolled in the study. Their ages ranged from 6 to 20 years with mean + SD of 13.7 + 3.1. Of the total, 53.3% were boys and 46.7% girls. The majority were of Saudi nationality (85.8%) and residents in Jeddah (80.6%). [Table 1] shows the sociodemographic characteristics of the disabled children in Jeddah City.
|Table 1: Sociodemographic characteristics of disabled children in governmental rehabilitation institutes of Jeddah|
Click here to view
Fathers' current ages ranged from 22 to 70 years (mean + SD of 44.9 + 9.7). Fathers' extreme age marriages [Table 2] were observed, with 16.9% of the fathers below the age of 20 years at the time of marriage, and 9.6% in this age group at the time of birth of their children. At the other extreme, 8.0% of the fathers married at the age of at least 50 years and 9.6% of them had children. Young fathers (<20 years) were more associated with having an auditory disabled child while older fathers (50+ years) were more likely to have a mentally disabled child (P<0.001). Around 27.9% of the fathers had never attended school and the highest proportion were among the parents of auditory disabled children, but results were not of statistical significance.
|Table 2 : Father's risk factors among mothers of children in Jeddah city by type of disability|
Click here to view
Unemployed fathers (11.5%) were more likely to have a visually and mentally disabled child. Also, 42.8% of the fathers had a military assignment and were prone to having children belonging to the mentally disabled cohorts.
The current mother's age ranged from 21 to 60 years (mean + SD: 39.4 + 8.1 years). As shown in [Table 3], mothers who married before their 16 th birthday accounted for 10.8% and those who gave birth before that age accounted for 3.0%. At the other extreme, mothers who married at 40 years or over accounted for 2.4% while those in this age group who gave birth accounted for 6.6%. Young maternal marital and childbearing ages were mainly observed among auditory disabled children while late marriages and childbearing were mainly associated with visual and mental disability (p < 0.001). Approximately, 53.4% of the mothers had never attended school and 95.9% did not work. Maternal illiteracy and unemployment were more marked among the auditory and mentally disabled cohorts (p<0.001). Multiparity at childbirth accounted for 30.8% and was marked among the visually and mentally disabled, but the results did not reach statistical significance. Consanguineous marriages were reported in approximately 51.3% of the cases, 75.7% of these were among first degree relatives.
|Table 3 : Mother's risk factors among disabled children in governmental rehabilitation institutes in Jeddah|
Click here to view
Consanguinity occurred more among the parents of the auditory disabled children (p<0.001).
As shown in [Table 4], past history of spontaneous abortion was mainly reported in the mothers of the auditory disabled (p<0.05), while fetal deaths and/or infant mortality were mainly seen among mothers of the visually disabled cohorts, but results did not reach statistical significance. Conditions that affected the mother during pregnancy, such as german measles, were reported for the auditory disabled, but the results were not significant. Threatened abortions and pre-eclampsia were reported mainly for the mothers of the visually disabled cohort (p<0.001). Severe prematurity (less than 28 weeks gestation) was observed more among the visually disabled children (p<0.001). There were more caesarian section deliveries, very low birthweight (less than 1500g), jaundice, oxygen therapy at birth and admission to neonatal intensive care units among the mentally disabled cohort (p<0.01).
|Table 4 : Mother's past history and perinatal risk factors among disabled children attending governmental rehabilitation institutes in Jeddah|
Click here to view
Six institutes offer education to disabled children up to the secondary level, using specially adapted syllabi. In every institute, in addition to the teaching staff there are a social worker, psychologist and a medical doctor. In varying proportions social, psychological, medical, and other educational services are offered to these children [Table 5]. The institutes which were best were those which cared for the auditory and the visual disablilities while those rated lowest were those institutes that cared for the mentally handicapped. In spite of the public informtion efforts of the rehabilitation institutes, most of the families of disabled children knew of these institutes only from their friends or neighbors; 99.2% of the auditory disabled, 73.2% of the visually disabled, and 92.3% of the mentally disabled children were taken to the institutes by their families, on their own. Those referred from primary health care units, school health and the private sectors were few and did not exceed 3.0%. Similarly, except for the visually disabled, who formed about 25.0% of those admitted to the institutes, those referred from the government hospitals were very few.
|Table 5 : Rehabilitation services offered to disabled children attending governmental rehabilitation institutes in Jeddah|
Click here to view
| Discussion|| |
Childhood disability is a public health concern since it affects the health and economic status of nations. The disabled child is a result of multiple factors. Most of these factors are modifiable by controlling the risk factors known to influence infant health and rectifying the quality of health services provided in our society.
The results of our study open multiple areas for research and discussion. They also aid in formulating hypotheses on determinants of childhood disability that could be restricted to the Middle East, illustrated by the conditions in the Kingdom.
This study has emphasized certain risk factors that still exist in our society. They include extreme age (early and late) of marriage and childbearing for both genders, as well as multiparity, illiteracy, unemployment and consanguineous marriages. Our results have shown that early marriage and childbearing, in both genders, have increased the risk of having an auditory disabled child. Arab countries as a whole are known to have a high rate of early marriages, a practice related to tradition and beliefs. ,,
It is true that early marriage and childbearing save the population from many health hazards but there should be a lower age limit for marriage and consequently childbearing, taking into account the biological maturity of both sexes. On the other hand, late childbearing maternal multiparity was also observed for both parents. In marriages that take place when the couples are old, child bearing in both genders tended to predispose to a mentally disabled child. Maternal multiparity predisposed to visually and mentally disability. Also, high parity, and thus pregnancies in old age, is typical for the Middle East region as documented in several studies. ,,,, Studies on the distribution of paternal age and its relation to child health are still lacking.
Illiteracy and unemployment were very high among the parents, especially the mothers. Illiterate jobless mothers were at higher risk of having an auditory and mentally disabled child. Illiterate fathers were more prone to have an auditory disabled child, while jobless fathers were more likely to have a mentally and visually disabled child. Illiteracy and unemployment are other factors previously reported in the region. ,
A healthy occupational environment is a second factor to be considered. Fathers engaged in military jobs were at a higher risk of having auditory and mentally disabled children. This occupation should be investigated as a possible risk factor that may influence the health of offspring. Previous investigations have shown that even after adjustment for the economic condition, an infant whose mother is illiterate is more likely to die during the postneonatal period than one whose mother is literate. ,
Female education is a major advantage to future health. Education improves women's awareness, which is reflected in the quality of her life. The higher the level of the woman's education, the healthier she will be because she will have healthier active life style, nutritional habits, economic conditions and personal hygiene. Female education motivates women to continue their careers, discourages early marriage, and provides better marriage prospects, and in the event of consanguineous marriage, it also makes them aware of the importance of premarriage counseling and availability of health care services. Moreover, education strengthens mother's awareness of the quality of life of her offspring when she follows appropriate feeding practices, and childcare, early detection and better management of life threatening conditions. In short, female education makes mothers more efficient in raising their children. ,
The father's education and work affect the family's well-being through a similar mechanism. However, research on paternal risk factors is still insufficient.
Consanguineous marriage is the dominant marriage pattern in many Third World countries, particularly in the Arab World. ,,,,,, Consanguinity is wide-spread in the Kingdom and is related to the culture. It was found in our data to be strikingly high, especially among first- degree relatives. This was more marked among parents of the auditory disabled.
Perinatal health is vital for child health and responsible for the pathogenesis of many health conditions. ,,,24 Perinatal care is the best means for improving maternal and child health. Unfortunately, few maternal and child health conditions during the perinatal period were available for analysis. Maternal factors included threatened abortion and pre-eclampsia and were observed more among mothers of the visually disabled cohorts. Severe preterm (before 28 weeks gestation) and very low birth weight (<1500g) births are other indicators for antenatal care. Prematurity was mainly observed among the visually disabled cohort, while the very low birthweights were more among the mentally disabled. Caesarian section deliveries were reported mainly in the mentally disabled children. Such postnatal conditions as jaundice, oxygen therapy and admission into a neonatal intensive care unit at birth were more prevalent among mentally disabled children.
A wide variety of services, including special education, social, psychological, medical and rehabilitation services are offered to the disabled children. These services are available for both genders, Saudis as well as non-Saudis, and residents of Jeddah City and surrounding areas. The service that ranked the lowest were the institutes that cared for mentally disabled children. This could be explained by the fact that these children are usually less capable than the other disabled, and were limited in what they would do and consequently overburdened the services offered to them. Nevertheless, participation of all professionals in the field is crucial in order to support the effort of the rehabilitation centers.
We conclude that much effort is required to reduce the incidence of future disability. This could be achieved through reducing the potential risk factors in our community and improving the quality of perinatal care and rehabilitation services in order to raise the quality of life for those infants who survive.
| References|| |
|1.||Rehabilitation International. Childhood disability: its prevention and rehabilitation. Assignment Children 1981; 53/54: 43-75. |
|2.||Marfo K. Childhood Disabilities in Developing Countries. New York: Praegar; 1985. |
|3.||Frayers T. The Epidemiology of Severe Intellectual Impairment: The Dynamic of Prevalence. Academic press; 1986. |
|4.||Milaat W. Public Health around the World: Saudi Arabia. Public Health Medicine 1999; 1:34-8. |
|5.||Al-Turaiki MH. National Project for Disability and Community Rehabilitation. King Fahad National Library: Riyadh; 1997. |
|6.||Harfouche JK, Verhoestrate LJ. Child Health. The State of Child Health in the Eastern Mediterranean Region. WHO/EMRO Technical Publication. 1983; 9:131-63. |
|7.||El Hamamsy L. Early Marriage and Reproduction in Two Egyptian Villages. Occasional Monograph, The Population Council/UNFPA 1994. |
|8.||Shawky S and Milaat W. Cumulative impact of early maternal marital age during the childbearing period. Paediatric and Perinatal Epid 2001; 15: 27-33. |
|9.||Milaat WA and DuV Florey CH. Perinatal Mortality in Jeddah, Saudi Arabia. Int J Epid 1992;21:82-90. |
|10.||Omran AR, Standely CC, Bone MR. Family formation and social structure. Introduction. In: Omran AR, Standley CC, (eds.) Family formation Patterns and Health. Further Studies. An international collaborative study in Colombia, Egypt, Pakistan and Syria. Geneva: WHO; 1981:101-2. |
|11.||Hammam H M, Zaraour A H A, El-Amine M, El Sharbini AF. Family formation and pregnancy outcome. Egypt. In: Omran A R Standley CC, editors. Family formation patterns and health. Further studies. An international collaborative study in Colombia, Egypt, Pakistan and Syria. Geneva: WHO 1981; 112-21. |
|12.||Bicego GT, Boerma JT. Maternal education and child survival: A comparative study of survey data from 17 countries. Social Science Medicine 1993; 36: 1207-27. |
|13.||Becerra J, Atrash H, Perez N, Saliceti JA. Low birthweight and infant mortality in Puerto Rico. American Journal of Public Health 1993; 83: 1572-6. |
|14.||Terra de Souza AC, Cufino E, Peterson KE, Gardner J, Vasconcelos do Amaral MI, Ascherio A. Variations in infant mortality rates among municipalities in state of Ceará, Northeast Brazil: an ecological analysis. Int J Epid 1999; 28:267-75. |
|15.||Shawky S, Milaat WM, Abalkhail BA, Soliman NK. Could maternal education explain excess rate of childhood handicap? A study in two maternity hospitals in Jeddah, Saudi Arabia. Saudi Medical Journal 2001; 22:841-4. |
|16.||Al-Salem M, Rawashdeh N. Consanguinity in North Jordan: Prevalence and pattern. J Biosoc Science 1993; 25:553-6. |
|17.||Gevi D, Nathan R, Freudilich M. Consanguinity and congenital heart disease in rural Arab population in Northern Israel. Human Hered 1986; 36:213-7. |
|18.||Hamamy HA, Al-Bayat N, Al-Qubaisy W. Consanguineous matings in the Iraq urban population and the effect of pregnancy outcome on infant mortality. Iraq Med J 1986; 34:65-80. |
|19.||Saha N, Hammad RE, Mahmoud S. Inbreeding effects on reproductive outcome in a Sudanese population. Hum Hered 1990; 40:208-12. |
|20.||Saha N, Al-Shaykh F. Inbreeding levels in Sudan. Biosoc Science 1998; 20:333-6. |
|21.||Zakzouk SM, Daghistani KJ, Jamal TS, Al-Shaikh AA, Hajjaj MF. A survey of childhood hearing impairment. Saudi Medical Journal 1999; 20:783-7. |
|22.||Weisglas-Kuperus N, Baerts W, de Graaf MA, van Zanten GA, Sauer PJ. Hearing and language in preschool very low birth weight children. Int J Pediatr Otorhinolaryngol 1993; 26:129-40. |
|23.||Borradori C, Fawer CL, Buclin T, Calame A. Risk factors for sensorineural hearing loss in preterm infants. Biol Neonate 1997: 71:1-10. |
[Table 1], [Table 2], [Table 3], [Table 4], [Table 5]